First Look at The Old Spaghetti Factory

Not to be confused with Spaghetti Warehouse or Spaghetti Works, the Portland-based chain The Old Spaghetti Factory opened their doors to the public. The chain Italian restaurant has arrived in Wichita and is located in the former Fox & Hound space at the Waterfront. We decided to bring the family along and check it out over the weekend.

1421 Waterfront Pkwy, Wichita, Kansas 67206

Sunday – Thursday: 11am – 10:30pm
Friday – Saturday: 11am – 10:30pm

Website |Facebook
Cash/Credit Card Accepted

This review also marked the first blog appearance for my daughter, Emery. She opted not to eat, but really loved the ambiance. It was so relaxing to her she slept through the entire lunch.

Regarding the interior, my girlfriend really loved the decor. From the light fixtures to the fabric on the seats, she commented multiple times and gazed around in awe.

Of course, the trolley car was a big focal point for their opening. It seats roughly 20 people and really caught everybody’s eyes as they walked in.

I was also joined by my brother and we had plans to really get a good in depth look of this restaurant. We started off with a couple of appetizers: the toasted ravioli and fried calamari. We enjoyed both of them. They each had a good breading ratio and fried well. The pomodoro sauce that came with the calamari was a big hit with everyone; it had a nice, refreshing herbal flavor that had a great aftertaste.

We were also given complimentary bread. And the server was telling us about mizithra cheese & browned butter; it was a special they had. We were told it was a sweeter tasting cheese and popular among many guests. He ended up bringing us a sample dish of it. The bread was fresh but everybody was floored by how good the mizithra cheese & browned butter sampler was. It was sweet but light and not so heavy.

For our main meals, everything we had was a 3-course meal. It came with a soup or salad, the main dish and a vanilla or spumoni ice cream dessert.

The starters weren’t anything special. They appeared to be your basic salads with dressing. There wasn’t anything that really set it apart from your simple house salad from any other restaurant. The same could have been said for the minestrone soup.

For our main dish, we had the spicy spaghetti vesuvius, garlic shrimp fettuccine, and the pot pourri which was a sampler of their different spaghetti offerings (mizithra cheese & browned butter, meat, clam and marinara sauce).

The spicy spaghetti vesuvius wasn’t anywhere near as spicy as my brother was expecting. I tried a little bit of it and it was very mild; he would have loved a little more heat on it. The flavor was there, but the expectation of the rest wasn’t. He still felt it was a good meal, but nothing memorable. As for the fettucine and spaghetti sampler dishes, we had a similar experience in that it wasn’t anything to write home about. We were definitely satisfied with our meals and weren’t unhappy with it. Not much in the way of flavors that hit your palate, all fairly simple stuff.

If you go to the Old Spaghetti Factory expecting mind-blowing or over the top meals, stop yourself. I hate to say the word “good” but that really was the best way to describe our meals. Aside from the mizithra cheese part of my pot pourri order, everything was just simple but not exactly memorable.

We all had the spumoni dessert which was pistachio cherry chocolate and loved every second of it. What we loved even more than that was the tiramisu. We liked the ratio of sponge to cream and well-balanced coffee and booze flavor. Just a great way to end our meal.

From a service standpoint, The Old Spaghetti Factory was phenomenal from all areas. It was opening week and it looked like they had staff from other locations in for help, but they were hitting on all cylinders. The service time for food was super quick, the drinks were constantly refilled and even tabbing out was a breeze. It’ll be interesting to see if the service quality can hold up over time.

For the food, it really didn’t stand out to us as this excellent meal to tell everyone about, but that’s not to say it wasn’t decent because it was. Everything there was fairly affordable and a great value especially by Waterfront standards. Many meals could be had for $10-13 and come with a salad and dessert, which we thought was a good selling point. Someone made a really good analogy, this place is kind of like the Applebee’s of Italian food.

Here’s their menu:

Happy Dining,

To nominate your restaurant or event to be considered for a review, please email us with your restaurant information. We are always open to suggestions.

Did you love the article and want to help the continuing free content at Wichita By E.B.? You can help keep our site going with a simple one-time or recurring donation. Your contribution is appreciated.


Buy Me A Coffee

If you’re a business owner and would like to be featured or partner up for a highlight, visit here.

1 thought on “First Look at The Old Spaghetti Factory”

  1. Eddy, I have to agree with this statement from your review about The Old Spaghetti Factory, “For the food, it really didn’t stand out to us as this excellent meal to tell everyone about but that’s not to say it wasn’t good because it was,” EXCEPT for the mizithra cheese & browned butter over angel hair pasta. I thought it was incredible and the next time I go to the OSF, I’ll order just that. I don’t know when I’ve eaten anything I’ve enjoyed more in a long time. I think that dish alone is worth a trip to the OSF.

    You note that “There wasn’t anything that really set it apart from your simple house salad from any other restaurant,” and I have to agree – in fact, I was disappointed in the salad and dressing – blue cheese. I think an excellent blue cheese dressing will have nice, large pieces of blue cheese in it. I saw one tiny piece of blue cheese in the dressing on my salad, which incidentally was iceberg lettuce – not impressive.

    I ordered chicken piccata and it was fine but not any different or better than chicken piccata I’ve eaten elsewhere. Still, OSF must be doing something right as the chain is celebrating its 50th year, this year. EB readers do go and try the mizithra cheese & browned butter over angel hair pasta – apparently, it’s the restaurant’s most famous and popular dish – you won’t be disappointed!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *